When it comes to deciding whether to pay off mortgage or invest in RRSP, the answer isn’t as straightforward as you might hope. Both options have significant financial implications and can shape your future in different ways. Let’s break it down so you can make an informed choice that works for your goals and lifestyle.
Table of Contents
Understanding the Basics
Before diving into the pros and cons, let’s clarify what each option entails.
Paying Off Your Mortgage
Paying off your mortgage means directing extra funds toward reducing your loan principal. The benefits? You become debt-free sooner and save money on interest over the life of the mortgage. Plus, owning your home outright can offer peace of mind and greater financial flexibility.
Investing in Your RRSP
Your Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) is a tax-advantaged investment account designed to help Canadians save for retirement. Contributions to your RRSP reduce your taxable income and allow your investments to grow tax-deferred. When you withdraw funds in retirement, you’ll pay tax on them, but ideally at a lower rate than during your working years.
Key Factors to Consider
When deciding whether to pay off mortgage or invest in RRSP, several factors come into play:
1. Interest Rates vs. Investment Returns
The interest rate on your mortgage versus the potential return on your RRSP investments is a critical consideration.
- Mortgage: Let’s say your mortgage has an interest rate of 4.5%. By paying it down early, you’re essentially earning a guaranteed 4.5% return on the money you’ve used to reduce your principal.
- RRSP: Meanwhile, if your RRSP investments generate an average return of 8% annually, your net return (after taxes) may still outperform the savings from paying off your mortgage.
Related content:
2. Tax Benefits
RRSP contributions come with immediate tax advantages. For example, if you earn $90,000 annually and contribute $10,000 to your RRSP, your taxable income drops to $80,000. This reduction means you pay less in taxes for the year, and depending on your marginal tax rate, it could result in a significant tax refund.
For instance, at a 29% marginal tax rate, a $10,000 contribution could lead to a refund of approximately $2,900. To maximize your savings, you can even reinvest your tax refund back into your RRSP, allowing your retirement savings to grow even faster through compounding.
Related content:
3. Time Horizon
Are you close to retirement or paying off your mortgage? If you’re nearing retirement and haven’t saved much for retirement, maximizing your RRSP could provide immediate tax benefits and boost your savings. However, if you’re years away from retirement but could pay off your mortgage in five years, eliminating that debt first might free up future income, giving you more room to invest for the long term.
4. Emotional and Financial Goals
What brings you peace of mind? Some people prioritize being debt-free, while others focus on maximizing their investments for long-term growth. Your comfort level with risk and debt plays a significant role in this decision.
Scenario Analysis
Let’s look at a few relatable examples to see how this decision might play out in real life.
Scenario 1: Young Professional with High RRSP Room
Emma is 30 years old, earns $85,000 annually, and has $20,000 in unused RRSP room. Her mortgage balance is $300,000 with a 4.5% interest rate. She has $10,000 in extra cash to allocate.
- Option A: Pay Off Mortgage
- By paying $10,000 toward her mortgage, Emma saves $450 in annual interest and reduces her principal faster.
- Option B: Invest in RRSP
- Contributing $10,000 to her RRSP reduces her taxable income to $75,000, saving her around $3,000 in taxes, assuming she resides in Ontario, Canada. If the RRSP grows at 8% annually, her investment could double in approximately 10 years.
In Emma’s case, the RRSP offers better financial returns in the long run, especially with the tax savings.
Scenario 2: Mid-Career Homeowner
Liam is 45 years old, earns $120,000 annually, and has a mortgage balance of $150,000 at a 4.5% interest rate. He also has $100,000 in his RRSP. He’s considering putting an extra $15,000 toward his mortgage or RRSP.
- Option A: Pay Off Mortgage
- Reducing his mortgage by $15,000 saves him $675 in annual interest.
- Option B: Invest in RRSP
- Contributing $15,000 to his RRSP reduces his taxable income to $105,000, resulting in approximately $5,900 in tax savings, assuming he resides in Ontario, Canada. Furthermore, this investment has the potential to grow significantly by the time he retires at 65.
For Liam, investing in his RRSP likely makes more sense due to the immediate tax savings and growth potential.
Scenario 3: Nearing Retirement
Sophia is 60 years old, earns $70,000 annually, and has a $40,000 mortgage balance at 4.5% interest. She’s also accumulated $200,000 in her RRSP. With an extra $10,000, she’s unsure where to put it.
- Option A: Pay Off Mortgage
- Paying $10,000 toward her mortgage saves $450 annually in interest and brings her closer to being debt-free before retirement.
- Option B: Invest in RRSP
- Contributing $10,000 to her RRSP saves her about $3,446 in taxes, assuming she resides in Ontario, Canada. However, with a shorter investment horizon, the returns may be limited.
In Sophia’s case, paying off her mortgage offers more peace of mind as she approaches retirement.
Pros and Cons of Each Option
Paying Off Your Mortgage
Pros:
- Guaranteed return equal to your mortgage interest rate. This is a risk-free way to save money on interest payments and reduce the overall cost of your home.
- Debt-free security. Eliminating a significant debt like your mortgage can provide a sense of financial stability and freedom.
- Frees up monthly cash flow. Once your mortgage is paid off, you’ll have more disposable income for other expenses or investments.
Cons:
- No immediate tax benefits. Unlike RRSP contributions, paying off your mortgage doesn’t reduce your taxable income or offer any direct tax savings.
- Missed opportunity for potentially higher investment returns. If your RRSP investments outperform your mortgage interest rate, you’re leaving money on the table.
Investing in Your RRSP
Pros:
- Immediate tax savings. Contributions to your RRSP lower your taxable income, potentially saving you thousands of dollars each year depending on your tax bracket.
- Long-term growth potential. Investments in an RRSP benefit from compounding returns, which can significantly grow your retirement savings over time.
- Compounded returns over time. The tax-deferred nature of RRSPs allows your investments to grow without being reduced by taxes until withdrawal.
Cons:
- Investment returns are not guaranteed. Unlike the certainty of paying down a mortgage, RRSP investments come with market risks and can fluctuate in value.
- Requires discipline to avoid withdrawing funds prematurely. Early withdrawals from your RRSP come with penalties and taxes, which can derail your long-term savings goals.
A Balanced Approach
If you’re torn, why not do both? Splitting your extra funds between paying off your mortgage and investing in your RRSP could give you the best of both worlds. Here’s how:
- Make a lump-sum mortgage payment: Use a portion of your funds to reduce your mortgage principal, which lowers your interest costs over time.
- Contribute to your RRSP: Invest the remaining amount to unlock tax savings and grow your retirement savings.
This balanced strategy helps you chip away at debt while building your financial future.
Bonus tip: You can also contribute to your RRSP and use the resulting tax refund to make an extra mortgage payment. It’s a win-win approach!
Final Thoughts
The decision to pay off mortgage or invest in RRSP depends on your financial situation, goals, and preferences. By considering factors like interest rates, tax benefits, and your time horizon, you can make a choice that aligns with your priorities.
Personal finance isn’t one-size-fits-all. Whether you value the peace of mind of being mortgage-free or the growth potential of your RRSP, the best decision is the one that supports your unique journey toward financial freedom.
What’s your preference? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
