If you’ve been diligently contributing to a Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP), you’re already ahead of the game in preparing for your child’s post-secondary education. But knowing how to withdraw those funds wisely is just as important as saving them in the first place. The right RESP withdrawal strategies can make a big difference in reducing taxes, avoiding penalties, and maximizing the funds available for education.
In this guide, we’ll explore how to create a smart withdrawal plan, minimize tax implications, and adapt to different scenarios like your child not pursuing post-secondary education. Whether your child is heading to college, university, or even trade school, you’ll find practical insights to make the most of your RESP.
1. Why RESP Withdrawal Strategies Are Important
RESPs (Registered Education Savings Plans) are a cornerstone of educational savings in Canada, offering unmatched advantages like tax-deferred growth and government grants such as the Canada Education Savings Grant (CESG). However, the real power of an RESP lies not just in saving, but in how you withdraw funds to cover your child’s post-secondary education costs effectively.
RESP withdrawals are broken into two main components:
Educational Assistance Payments (EAPs):
- Composed of CESG and any investment income earned in the account.
- Taxable in the student’s hands.
Post-Secondary Education (PSE) Withdrawals:
- These are the contributions you made to the RESP.
- Tax-free when withdrawn since you’ve already paid taxes on this money.
Understanding these components and planning your withdrawals properly can save you thousands in taxes, avoid grant repayments, and ensure you make the most of your hard-earned savings.
Related content:
2. What is the Maximum RESP Withdrawal Amount?
The maximum withdrawal amount from a Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) depends on the type of funds being accessed: contributions or Educational Assistance Payments (EAPs).
Contributions—money you initially put into the RESP—can be withdrawn at any time and in any amount since they aren’t taxable. However, EAPs, which consist of government grants like the Canada Education Savings Grant (CESG) and investment earnings, are subject to limits and taxation when withdrawn.
For EAPs, the maximum withdrawal during the first 13 weeks of your child’s full-time post-secondary program is capped at $8,000. After this period, there’s no fixed cap, but withdrawals must match the student’s educational expenses, such as tuition, books, and living costs. For part-time studies, the withdrawal limit for EAPs is $4,000 per 13-week period.
If you exceed these limits or cannot justify the withdrawal amount with eligible expenses, there’s a risk of penalties or grant repayment to the government.
3. Breaking Down Tax Implications
One of the first things to understand about RESP withdrawals is the tax treatment of EAPs. Since they are taxed in the hands of the student, this can work to your advantage. Most students have little to no income during their post-secondary years, meaning they fall into the lowest tax bracket (or even pay no taxes at all).
3.1 Minimizing Taxes on EAPs
Here are a few strategies to minimize taxes:
- Spread Out Withdrawals: Avoid withdrawing large sums of EAPs in a single year. This could push your child into a higher tax bracket. Instead, spread withdrawals evenly over their education.
- Withdraw During Low-Income Years: If your child works part-time or receives scholarships, their taxable income may be higher than expected. Plan RESP withdrawals for years when their income is lower to avoid unnecessary taxes.
- Maximize Basic Personal Amounts: Ensure withdrawals don’t exceed your child’s basic personal amount (which is $15,705 federally and $12,399 for Ontario for 2024). This keeps their tax bill as low as possible.
Example: Tax Planning with EAPs
Let’s assume your child has $10,000 in EAPs available annually. The basic personal amount for 2024 is $15,705 federally and $12,399 for Ontario.
- Scenario 1: Your child has no other income.
- The $10,000 EAP withdrawal falls below the basic personal amount, resulting in zero federal taxes.
- Scenario 2: Your child works part-time and earns $6,000 annually.
- Their total income becomes $16,000 ($10,000 earnings + $6,000 EAP). After applying the exemptions of $15,705 federally and $12,399 for Ontario, only $295 is taxable federally and $3,601 is taxable in Ontario, keeping their tax liability minimal.
3.2 Handling CESG and Limits
The CESG is a wonderful boost to your RESP savings, but it comes with limits. The maximum lifetime CESG withdrawal is $7,200 per child. Exceeding this amount will require repaying any excess to the government. Keeping track of CESG usage is critical to avoid complications.
Example of CESG Tracking:
- Total RESP balance: $56,000 (including $36,000 contributions and $20,000 in CESG and growth).
- You plan to withdraw $5,000 in Educational Assistance Payments (EAPs) per semester. Over four years (8 semesters), this will total $40,000, comprising $7,200 in Canada Education Savings Grant (CESG) funds, $12,800 in investment income and $20,000 contributions.
By keeping within the CESG limits, you avoid the risk of grant clawbacks.
4. Aligning Withdrawals with Expenses
A well-planned RESP withdrawal strategy matches the timing and amount of withdrawals to your child’s educational expenses. Tuition, books, rent, groceries, and transportation are all eligible expenses under RESP rules.
4.1 Starting with EAPs
Since EAPs are taxable, it’s often smart to prioritize these withdrawals during your child’s early school years when their taxable income is lowest. This approach allows you to save your tax-free PSE contributions for later expenses.
4.2 Matching Withdrawals to Real Needs
Rather than withdrawing RESP funds all at once or in arbitrary amounts, tie your withdrawals to actual costs. For instance:
- In the first semester, calculate tuition, books, and living expenses for the next 4-6 months. Withdraw just enough RESP funds to cover these.
- Reassess costs before each new semester or academic year.
Example: Matching Withdrawals to Expenses
Let’s assume your child’s annual post-secondary expenses are:
- Tuition: $8,000
- Books and supplies: $1,200
- Rent: $10,000
- Living expenses (groceries, transit, etc.): $6,000
Total annual cost: $25,200
Let’s say you’ve saved $80,000 in an RESP for your daughter. This includes $50,000 in your contributions and $30,000 in government grants and investment earnings. Here’s how you can structure the RESP withdrawals:
- Year 1: Withdraw $10,000 in EAPs to cover tuition and books. Use $15,200 in PSE contributions for rent and living expenses.
- Year 2: Similar to Year 1, but adjust based on actual costs and investment growth.
- Year 3-4: Decrease EAPs if taxable income rises due to part-time work, covering more expenses with PSE contributions.
This balanced approach ensures all costs are met while minimizing taxes on EAP withdrawals.
4.3 Avoiding over Withdrawal
Withdrawing too much in one go can have unintended consequences, like triggering higher taxes or leaving less money for future years. On the flip side, withdrawing too little may leave unused RESP funds subject to restrictions or penalties later.
5. Adapting for Different Scenarios
Every family’s situation is different, and your RESP withdrawal strategy should reflect your unique circumstances. Below, we’ll explore some common scenarios and how to handle them.
Scenario 1: Your Child Pursues a Full-Time Degree
This is the ideal scenario for RESP withdrawals. With steady, predictable expenses, you can plan to use EAPs first and save your contributions (PSEs) for later expenses like living costs or graduation needs.
Scenario 2: Your Child Works Part-Time
If your child has a part-time job, they may have higher taxable income. Be mindful of how RESP withdrawals interact with their income to avoid pushing them into a higher tax bracket. Adjust withdrawals to optimize their basic personal amount.
For example, if they earn $10,000 annually and withdraw $6,000 in EAPs, their total income would be $16,000. This exceeds the 2024 basic personal amounts of $15,705 federally and $12,399 for Ontario. In this case:
- Plan withdrawals during lower-income years.
- Use more PSE contributions to cover costs, reducing taxable income.
Scenario 3: Your Child Doesn’t Pursue Post-Secondary Education
If your child decides not to attend college or university, you still have options:
- Transfer RESP Funds to an RRSP: If you have unused RRSP contribution room, you can transfer up to $50,000 of RESP income into an RRSP without tax penalties.
- Withdraw Contributions: You can take back your original contributions tax-free.
- Repay Grants: Any unused CESG or other grants must be returned to the government.
Scenario 4: Your Child Attends Part-Time
RESP funds can still be used for part-time studies, but EAP withdrawals may be capped. You’ll need proof of enrollment in a qualifying program to access these funds. The withdrawal limit in 2024 for part-time students is $4,000 for every 13-week period of enrollment.
6. Maximizing Tax-Free Withdrawals
Your original contributions are tax-free, making them a critical part of your RESP strategy. While it’s tempting to withdraw contributions early, there are advantages to holding off:
- Save for Later Years: Contributions can cover large expenses like rent or travel during your child’s final years of study.
- Keep Flexibility: Unlike EAPs, which have stricter rules, contributions can be withdrawn anytime for any purpose, giving you more freedom in managing funds.
Example: Leveraging Tax-Free Withdrawals in Final Years
In the final year of study, your child decides to attend a study-abroad program, increasing costs to $35,000.
- Withdraw the remaining $15,000 in EAPs (if taxable income allows).
- Use $20,000 in PSE contributions to cover additional expenses without tax implications.
7. Timing Is Everything
Timing plays a big role in RESP withdrawal strategies. Here are a few time-sensitive tips:
- Start Early: Begin withdrawals in your child’s first year of study. This allows you to spread EAPs over multiple years, minimizing tax implications.
- Use Up Grants First: Since CESG and other grants must be used for educational purposes, prioritize withdrawing them early in your child’s post-secondary journey.
- End Strategically: In the final year of study, ensure you’ve fully utilized grants and investment income to avoid penalties or repayment.
8. Common Mistakes to Avoid
Even with the best intentions, it’s easy to make mistakes when managing RESP withdrawals. Here are some pitfalls and how to steer clear of them:
Mistake 1: Over-withdrawing EAPs
Exceeding the annual or lifetime CESG limits can trigger repayment of grants. Keep track of how much you withdraw each year and plan within these limits.
Mistake 2: Waiting Too Long
RESPs have a lifespan. Funds must be used within 35 years of the account opening date. Waiting too long to withdraw could result in forfeited grants and penalties on unused income.
Mistake 3: Failing to Document Expenses
Always keep receipts for tuition, textbooks, and other qualified expenses. These records will be invaluable if you’re ever audited or need to prove the funds were used appropriately.
9. A Real-Life Example
Let’s consider a hypothetical family to illustrate how these strategies come together:
- The Situation: Rob and Helen, based in Ontario, saved $76,000 in an RESP for their daughter, Dianne. This includes $36,000 in contributions (PSEs) and $40,000 in government grants and investment earnings (EAPs).
- Year 1: Dianne enrolls in university and works part-time, earning $6,000 a year. Rob and Helen withdraw $6,000 in EAPs for her tuition and books, keeping her income under the basic personal amount.
- Year 2-3: They withdraw $11,000 in EAPs each year to cover tuition, rent, and additional expenses, spreading out withdrawals to minimize taxes.
- Year 4: In Dianne’s final year, they use the remaining $12,000 in EAPs and $20,000 in PSE contributions to cover graduation costs and a study-abroad program.
By planning withdrawals carefully, Rob and Helen avoid overpaying taxes and make the most of their RESP savings. Dianne’s taxable income in each year (Years 1-4) remains below the basic personal amount. As a result, she is not expected to owe any federal or provincial taxes.
10. What Happens When It’s Time to Close the RESP?
When your child has finished their education, you’ll need to wind down the RESP. Here’s how to do it effectively:
- Withdraw Remaining Contributions: Your original contributions can be taken out tax-free.
- Use Up Grants and Earnings: Make sure any remaining CESG or investment income is withdrawn for education-related expenses.
- Transfer Funds: If there’s money left over, consider transferring it to an RRSP (if you have room) or to another child’s RESP.
Related content:
Final Thoughts on RESP Withdrawal Strategies
RESPs are an invaluable tool for funding education, but their benefits depend heavily on how you manage withdrawals. By aligning RESP withdrawal strategies with your child’s needs, keeping tax implications in mind, and planning for different scenarios, you can maximize your savings and reduce unnecessary costs.
Whether your child pursues a degree, takes a different path, or works part-time, a thoughtful withdrawal plan ensures your hard-earned savings achieve their intended purpose—empowering your child’s future.
